Compare cruise lines · Value to luxury ladder
Carnival, Celebrity or Regent?
Three very different ways to go to sea. Fun, polished premium, or all-inclusive luxury.
| Compare | Carnival | Celebrity | Regent |
|---|---|---|---|
| The mood | Casual, high-energy, pool-deck first. Fun is the point, not hush. | Modern, design-led, a notch quieter than Carnival or Royal Caribbean. Edge-class ships are the current look. | Quiet, destination-led, country-club rather than showbiz. People dress for dinner because they like to. |
| Best for | First-time cruisers, families, groups of friends, and anyone who wants a lively ship without a dress-code anxiety. | Couples and friends in their 30s to 60s who care about food and the ship as a place, not only the itinerary. | Affluent, often 50+, many repeat guests, people who have already done the big-ship circuit. |
| Relative cost | $$. Value / contemporary. Often the most approachable fare in the mass-market set - before packages. | $$$. Premium. Above contemporary megaship pricing; below true all-inclusive luxury. | $$$$. Ultra-luxury, typically sold as all-inclusive. The fare is high; the extras list is short. |
| Inclusions | Drinks: Extra, unless you buy a package; Tips: Auto-added daily; can be adjusted; Wi-Fi: Extra; Specialty dining: Extra; Excursions: Extra | Drinks: Extra unless you take a drinks package or a fare that bundles it; Tips: Usually extra unless packaged; Wi-Fi: Extra unless packaged; Specialty dining: Extra unless packaged; Excursions: Extra | Drinks: Included (wines, spirits, in-suite); Tips: Included; Wi-Fi: Included; Specialty dining: Included; Excursions: A generous included-shore programme on most sailings; some premium tours extra |
| Dining | Main dining room and a busy buffet included. Specialty restaurants cost extra. | Included main venues are better than contemporary. Specialty restaurants are a genuine reason to sail here, and they cost extra unless packaged. | Specialty restaurants included. Reservations still matter on sea days. |
| Who it fits | A first cruise, a family week, a group that wants energy and a fair price, Caribbean and short-haul sailings. | Couples who want a nicer ship and better food than contemporary, without paying ultra-luxury all-inclusive rates. Europe, Alaska, Caribbean, and the Galápagos (a separate small-ship product). | Travellers who want one price, serious destinations, and a small enough ship that the crowd never feels like a queue. World segments, Europe, Alaska, Asia. |
| The catch | Crowds at peak, extra charges add up, and it is not a quiet ship. If you want silence at 11am by the pool, look elsewhere. | Packages and extras can close the gap with luxury pricing. Not the right first choice for families with young children who want waterparks. | The fare. Less energy if you like a party ship. Overkill for a 4-night Bahamas party. Club Mariner is select sailings only - do not book expecting a daily kids’ club. |
Ready for a shortlist?
Tell us who is travelling and roughly when. We reply within one working day with two or three ships and a price, no obligation.
Cruise inclusions and policies vary by ship, market and sailing. We confirm the live fare and inclusions before recommending or booking. Compare all 12 lines.